the
M
yanMar
t
iMes
4
n
ews
August 20 - 26, 2012
From page 1
myanmar
times
t H e
m m
t i m e s
. c o m
Managing Director and Editor-in-Chief (MTE)
Ross Dunkleyrsdunkley@gmail.com
Chief Executive Officer & Editor-in-Chief (MTM)
Dr. Tin Tun Oodrtto@myanmartimes.com.mm
Chief Operating Officer
–
U Wai Linnwailin@myanmartimes.com.mm
EDITORIAL
newsroom@myanmartimes.com.mm
Editor MTE
– Thomas Keantdkean@gmail.com
Editor MTM
– U Zaw Myinteditormtm@myanmartimes.com.mm
Editor Special Publications
–
U Myo Lwinmyolwin@myanmartimes.com.mm
Deputy Editor MTM
– U Sann Oo
Business Editor MTE
– Stuart Deedstuart.deed@gmail.com
Business Editor MTM
– U Tin Moe Aung
Property Editor MTM
–
Htar Htar Khinproperty@myanmartimes.com.mm
World Editor MTE
–
Geoffrey Goddardgeoffrey@myanmartimes.com.mm
Timeout and Travel Editor MTE
–
Douglas Long
editors@myanmartimes.com.mm
Timeout Editor MTM
–
Moh Moh Thawmohthaw@gmal.com
Deputy News Editor
– Kyaw Hsu Mon
Chief Political Reporter
–
U Soe Than Lynn
Contributing Editor
–
Ma Thanegima.thanegi19@gmail.com
Head of Translation Dept
– U Ko Ko
Head of Photographics
– Kaung Htet
Photographers
– Y
ad
anar, Boothee
Book Publishing Consultant Editor
–
Col Hla Moe (Retd)
Editor:
U Win
T
un
Mandalay Bureau Chief
– U Aung Shinkoshumgtha@gmail.com
Nay Pyi Taw Bureau Chief
– U Soe Than Lynnsoethanlynn@gmail.com
PRODUCTION
production@myanmartimes.com.mm
Head of Production & Press Scrutiny Liaison
–U Aung Kyaw Oo (1)
Head of Graphic Design
– U Tin Zaw Htway
MCM PRINTING
printing@myanmartimes.com.mm
Head of Department
– U Htay Maung
Warehouse Manager
– U Ye Linn Htay
Factory Administrator
–
U Aung Kyaw Oo (3)
Factory Foreman
– U Tin Win
ADVERTISING
advertising@myanmartimes.com.mm
National Sales Director
Daw Khin Thandar Htaysales-director@myanmartimes.com.mm
Account Director
–
U Nyi Nyi Tun
Classifieds Manager
–
Daw Khin Mon Mon Yiclassified@myanmartimes.com.mm
ADMIN & FINANCEFinance Manager
– Daw Mon Mon Tha Saingfinance@myanmartimes.com.mm
HR Manager
–
Daw Nang Maisyadministration@myanmartimes.com.mm
Publisher
– Dr Tin Tun Oo, Permit No: 04143
Systems Manager
–
U Khin Maung Thawwebmaster@myanmartimes.com.mm
DISTRIBUTION & CIRCULATION
Manager
– U Ko Ko Aungdistmgr@myanmartimes.com.mmcirculation@myanmartimes.com.mm
ADVERTISING & SUBSCRIPTI
ON ENQ
UIRIES
Telephone: (01) 253 642, 392 928Facsimile: (01) 254 158Email: administration@myanmartimes.com.mmThe Myanmar Times is owned by MyanmarConsolidated Media Ltd and printed by MCMCommercial Printing (licence provided by SwesoneMedia (08102) with approval from MCM Ltd andby Shwe Zin Press (0368) with approval fromMCM Ltd). The title The Myanmar Times, in eitherEnglish or Myanmar languages, its associated logosor devices and the contents of this publication maynot be reproduced in whole or in part without thewritten consent of the Managing Director of MyanmarConsolidated Media Ltd.
Myanmar Consolidated Media Ltd.www.mmtimes.comHead Office:
379/383 Bo Aung Kyaw Street,Kyauktada Township, Yangon, Myanmar.Telephone: (01) 253 642, 392 928Facsimile: (01) 392 706
Mandalay Bureau:
No.178, 74
th
Street, (Bet. 31
st
&32
nd
streets) Chan Aye Thar San Townshp, Mandalay.
Tel: (02) 24450, 24460, 65391, 65392Fax: (02) 24460Email: mdybranch@myanmartimes.com.mm
Nay Pyi Taw Bureau:
No. 10/72 Bo Tauk HteinSt, Yan Aung (1) Quarter, Nay Pyi Taw-Pyinmana.Tel: (067) 23064, 23065Email: capitalbureau@myanmartimes.com.mm
Migration could fuel
“We don’t like the strangersentering into our country withoutany control or any rules.”Chinese migrants are alsosettling in border areas of Kachin State, said Daw BawkJa, a National Democratic Forcepolitician and land rights activistfrom Hpakant township.“The problem of non-citizenssettling inside Myanmar ishappening not only in RakhineState but also Kachin and Shanstates. Chinese people are alsoexpanding their businesses here.If a Chinese person wants to getan NRC, they can get it straightaway by paying K1 million orK1.5 million,” she said.“But while this is happening,some Myanmar nationals haven’teven been able to get an NRC yet.This is because of some corruptlow-ranking government staff,”she said.“Because of these non-citizensentering the country, our youngpeople are becoming addicted todrugs and young ladies are alsobeing trafficked. If we don’t reallyprevent this from happening inthe future, the situation in ourcountry will get worse.”U Hla Maung Shwe, abusinessman and senior figurein non-government organisationMyanmar Egress who has beeninvolved in the peacebuildingefforts of the past year, saidillegal immigration had alwaysoccurred but was more evidentthan before.However, he urged againsthasty “solutions” to the issue andsaid the government was workingon longer term resolutions.“This case has to be settledgradually. The current presidenthas also handled it gently. TheMinistry of Immigration andPopulation is also consideringthe issue. We’ve found that theyare trying to ensure this kind of thing does not happen again inthe future,” he said.National League for Democracyspokesperson U Nyan Win saidthe ministry needed to be heldresponsible for allowing non-citizens to easily enter Myanmarfrom neighbouring countries.“The rights or wrongs of thelower ranking officers are theresponsibility of the higher levels.There will be fewer mistakesoccurring if the region or districtlevel officials supervise their staff more closely,” he said.“There are armed
kathe
[inChin State and Sagaing Region]… if there is no supervision[of government officials], thesearmed people will keep comingin the future,” he added.For now, however, it is theconflict in Rakhine State that hascaptured the attention of not onlyMyanmar nationals but peopleall over the world.U Zaw Aye Maung, Ministerfor Rakhine Affairs in YangonRegion, said all Myanmar citizenshad to cooperate to resolve theconflict.“This case not only concernsthe people of Rakhine State. Itconcerns the whole country,”he said.
– Translated by Thiri Min Htun
Public company
He did not disclose how sharesin the public company would besold or whether there would bean initial public offering.U Aye Lwin, the chair of Dagon Seikkan IndustrialZone management committee,confirmed the news last week.“Yes, we have got theinstruction to develop the projectby forming a public company.UMFCCI has taken a leadingrole in forming the company andhas now started the necessarytasks. The ownership ratio isMyanmar 51 percent, Japan49pc. The whole 51pc will beowned by that public company,”he said.Mr Hideaki Matsuo, counsellorat the Japanese embassy in Yangon, said “all types” of Japanese firms would be involvedin the project.“[Thilawa port] is going tobe developed with the specialeconomic zone. It will start soonbut there is no exact date,” hesaid, adding that funding wouldcome from both public and privatesources in Japan.The Thilawa Special EconomicZone is in Thanlyin township,across the Bago River from Yangon. The governmentannounced the project about 10years ago but it never got off theground; recent media reportssuggested that businesses andorganisations from China,Singapore, Malaysia and Japanhad submitted proposals to startdevelopment in the area.U Win Aung said onlyJapanese and Myanmar firmswere involved in the project andalso denied rumours that someland had already has been leasedto foreign companies, adding thatthe government owns all the landin the project area.The zone is next to MyanmarInternational Terminal Thilawaand because it is close to Yangonand the fact some infrastructureis already in place it is likelyto develop faster than othereconomic zones, such as Dawei,say government officials.U David Abel, a formerMinister for National Planningand Economic Development,told
The Myanmar Times
inan interview last month thatnon-existent infrastructure hadhampered the development of industrial zones such as Thilawasince they were first proposed. Hewarned that foreign companiesmight only be attracted to thezones by the offer of free or cheapland.“The special economic zoneprojects were initiated when Iwas [a minister],” he said.“But insufficient infrastructurehurt potential developers’confidence in them.“Just giving land alone can’tattract the investors, althoughmaybe giving land to investors onlong-term leases without chargeswould work.“The necessary [infrastructure]for implementing special economiczones is significant, includingelectricity, water, transportation,telecommunications, bankingsystems, accommodation forinvestors and nothing is readyso far.He said the state had aresponsibility to provide thisinfrastructure and if it couldnot afford to then it should seekloans.“But floating shares is the bestway to get money for developinginfrastructure for both localand international investors. Ihave been suggesting this sincelong ago as a way of moving theprojects forward. I suggestedto float shares designed forforeigners as well. But for thatto work we need to have stronglegal infrastructure to protectownership,” he said.
– Additional reporting by Tim McLaughlin
By Soe Than Lynn
PYITHU Hluttaw SpeakerThura U Shwe Mann last weekcalled for the resignation of thechairman and members of theConstitutional Tribunal overtheir ruling earlier this yearthat parliamentary committeesare not union-level bodies.Reading out a formal messagehe sent to the president on August 8, the speaker saidhe would prefer the tribunalmembers resign voluntarily andset an August 21 deadline. If they do not resign, the hluttawwill establish a tribunal to hearthe impeachment case.The speaker said he sent themessage after hundreds of MPsrequested permission to impeachmembers of the tribunal undersections 334(a)(ii) and (v) of theconstitution, which allows themto be removed for breaching“any of the provisions under theconstitution” and “inefficientdischarge of duties assigned bylaw” respectively.The case was heard afterthe attorney general, on behalf President U Thein Sein, filed asubmission to the tribunal onFebruary 2 asking for clarificationover whether parliamentarybodies are considered union-level. Pyithu Hluttaw DeputySpeaker U Nanda Kyaw Swarfronted the tribunal on February17 to outline the hluttaw’s stanceand was present when the verdictwas read out on March 28.But Thura U Shwe Mann saidthe tribunal’s decision was “notconsistent” with the constitutionas it contravened laws governingthe parliament’s activities. Hetold MPs he would also askthe president to withdraw thesubmission that provoked thecase.“The tribunal decidedthat defining committees,commissions and bodies formedby each hluttaw as union-level bodies was not consistentwith the provisions of theconstitution. The tribunal isnot allowed to make a decisionthat is contrary to the provisionsof the existing laws, such asthe Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Law,the Pyithu Hluttaw Law andthe Amyotha Hluttaw Law,”Thura U Shwe Mann said on August 14.“When making this decision,the tribunal has made a mistakewithout caring about the law. Asa result, it has hurt the dignityof representatives, and causedlimitations and hindranceswhen carrying out the tasksof the hluttaw and MPs, thediscussions by MPs, as the joint Pyidaungsu Hluttaw BillCommittee has pointed out.The speaker said he had triedto resolve the issue by delayingan impeachment order from MPsand meeting with President UThein Sein to discuss the issue.However, the issue had cometo a head now because of thedecision’s implications for therecently formed Rule of Law andTranquility Committee led byDaw Aung San Suu Kyi.“On April 12, during the thirdPyithu Hluttaw session, 191MPs signed and submittedto me via the Hluttaw RightsCommittee’s chairman to submitan urgent proposal to impeachthe tribunal’s chairman andparty,” he said.“I made it pending andsubmitted the matter to thepresident and the presidentsaid he would work to resolveit. Although a meeting withthe people concerned was helduntil now it hasn’t borne fruit. As a result, 301 MPs havesigned and submitted anotherpetition. But I am going to senda formal message to try to findan alternative way.“As a speaker, I understandthat I have to fulfil what MPsfairly demand and have entrustedme to do. However, I don’t wantto make this accusation.”U Nanda Kyaw Swar told thehluttaw he had been forced to“stand for one hour listening tothe [tribunal’s] wrong decision”on March 28.“The wrong decision not onlyhurts and delays the tasks of the hluttaw and MPs but alsohinders amending the PyithuHluttaw Law,” he said.“Because the tribunal wasnot efficient and did not followthe transitional provisions of chapter 14 of the constitution,about 200 MPs submitted toimpeach them on April 26. Theywaited because the Speakersaid he would resolve andMPs be patient. Now manywriters have written critiques[on this issue] in newspapersand journals. Online writerssaid that the formation of therule of law and stability andpeace committee headed byDaw Aung San Suu Kyi fromKawhmu was not consistentwith the constitution so morethan 300 MPs re-submitted”the proposal to impeach thetribunal’s members.“Thank you for yourunderstanding and acceptancethe first time and the secondtime the speaker requestedyou. We are waiting until nowwith love, loyalty and sympathyin our mind … the best thingwould be if negotiation pays off,without us having to make thisaccusation.”Daw Aung San Suu Kyi andother NLD MPs were among therepresentatives who signed thepetition to impeach the tribunalchairman and members, amember of the Pyithu HluttawRights Committee said.–
Translated by Thit Lwin
Hluttaw sets Aug 21 deadlinefor tribunal members to resign